simardcasanova’s avatarsimardcasanova’s Twitter Archive—№ 27,013

  1. …in reply to @undefined
    @ZOEconomy @SarahJacobsonEc I am not pointing any finger here! But I think I need to say that I have *never* encountered a single person who took this criticism as a legitimate criticism and/or an good faith attempt to improve the work/paper in question. I am not claiming my sample is representative, but…
    simardcasanova’s avatar Mood +2 🙂
    1. …in reply to @simardcasanova
      @ZOEconomy @SarahJacobsonEc … I am questioning the empirical effects of using this kind of criticism to the person who receive it
      Permalink simardcasanova’s avatar Mood -1 🙁
      1. …in reply to @simardcasanova
        @ZOEconomy @SarahJacobsonEc I am also wondering how we establish what econ is. Is it a method? A set of research questions? Who decide then? In my experience, this critique was mostly (if not exclusively) made by people with academic power/a strong scientific reputation
        Permalink simardcasanova’s avatar ❤️ 1 Favorite Mood 0
        1. …in reply to @simardcasanova
          @ZOEconomy @SarahJacobsonEc Most importantly, are we sure that we don’t deter scholars (including young ones) to do important work that would ultimately benefit economics with this kind of criticism? (Either by making them leave the field/academia and/or work on something else)
          Permalink simardcasanova’s avatar Mood +3 🙂